When you purchase through links on our internet site , we may take in an affiliate commission . Here ’s how it do work .
When confronted with surveys asking for tallness and weight information , most people rest , a young study finds . These mistruths probably are n’t large enough to skew data on internal obesity levels , but they could make it harder to liken fleshiness rates among different ethnic groups .
lily-white respondents are more potential to underestimate their body hatful forefinger ( BMI ) , a measure of height and weight that approximatesbody fatness , than black or Hispanic the great unwashed , accord to the raw subject field . However , under - reporting weighting and over - report height are common in all ethnic groups . ( overrate height and underestimating exercising weight would lead to a lower BMI . )
People usually underestimate their weight and overestimate their height on surveys, new research confirms..
That ’s of import because many torso - weight survey rely on participant to report their summit and weight themselves , as weigh and measure them would be time and money .
withal , the reporting error are small — within the 1 BMI - unit range — and are thus unconvincing to affect the overallpicture of obesityin America , pronounce field of study researcher Ming Wen , a sociologist at the University of Utah . accord to theGallup polling agency , 36.6 percent of Americans are " normal weight , " while 35.8 percent are heavy and 25.8 pct obese . ( For adult , typically a BMI of 18.5 – 24.9 is considered normal weight , 25 – 29.9 overweight and 30 or greater obese . )
" In terms of studies examining risk factors of obesity , I do n’t recall the under - reportage is a immense trouble , " Wen pronounce in a statement .
Using date from the 2007 - 2008 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey ( NHANES ) , the researchers examined height and weightiness reports along with actual measurements from 2,672 human race and 2,671 cleaning lady .
Men tend to overvalue their pinnacle by an average of about a half - column inch ( 1.41 centimetre ) , and women by 0.33 in ( 0.84 cm ) , the study found . inglorious men more or less overestimate their system of weights , but all other group underestimate , by as little as 0.09 Irish punt ( 0.04 kg ) among lily-white men to 3.8 pounds ( 1.74 kg ) among black women .
Taking both weightiness and summit misrepresentations into account , women underrate BMI more than man do , and white women underestimate BMI more than women of other ethnicities . This may be because afixation on thinnessis more common in whites , the authors wrote in the winter 2012 issue of the journal Ethnicity and Disease .
Overweight people , those over age 60 and multitude with a college Department of Education were also more likely to underestimate their BMI .
The results show that researchers need to be careful when comparingobesity ratesacross demographic , Wen said , because the groups may not be under- and overestimating their BMI at the same rate .
